The ability to publish papers in the core journal is a high recognition of the researchers’ achievements, but a “god paper” published in the Chinese’s core journal, Glacial Permafrost, has shocked everyone. It is reported that “Glacial Permafrost” by the Chinese Academy of Sciences in the cold zone dry area of the Institute of Environment and Engineering, the Chinese Geographical Society, is China’s ice, snow, permafrost and frozen circle in the field of the only academic journal-level academic journals,
He has been awarded honors such as China Top 100 Newspapers (2015), China Fine Science and Technology Journal (2017), China International Influential Outstanding Academic Journal (2018), and has been included in the Chinese Core Journal Overview (North University Core), China Science and Technology Core Journal (CSTPCD), and China Science Citation Database (CSCD).
In the 5th issue of 2013, Glacial Permafrost published a paper entitled The Theory and Practice (II) of the Integrated Framework for Eco-Economics, which at first glance is very professional:
But to the fourth section, the picture wind suddenchange, the title is actually “the noble sense of the teacher and the teacher’s sense of beauty of the inheritance”, under a proper discussion of the mentor and teacher mother, the period of not sleay beautiful words, but also specially produced pictures and tables to express the worship of the mentor and teacher.
In addition, in the literature section of the paper citation, almost all of the author’s own papers appear. You know, the citation rate of the thesis is an important criterion for scientific research evaluation.
For such a strange paper, netizens are also silent: “the author really dare to write, the magazine really dare to publish.” “”Some netizens pointed out that his mentor was the editor-in-chief of the journal. “”Fallen to the extreme. “”It’s all 0202 years old. “
In fact, in the same issue of the journal Glacial Permafrost, other papers are normal and serious, such as “The Changing Characteristics of Meteorological Elements during the Polar Day at Zhongshan Station in Antarctica”, “Space-time distribution of the snow cover of mount Everest Nature Reserve in the Himalayas 2001-2010”, 1961-2010 Xinjiang thunderstorm space-time distribution and its changing characteristics.
It is worth mentioning that, after media mining, the author’s other papers suspect similar problems exist.
After the incident came to light, “Glacial Permafrost” magazine issued a withdrawal statement today, acknowledging that the article before the publication of the review is not strict, after the editorial board review, decided to “the theory and practice of the ecological economics integration framework” article to withdraw the draft.
However, according to netizens found that this paper still exists in China.com.