Why the Chinese disease control paper is published so fast: New crown related papers published only 48 hours

In response to the Publication of a new coronavirus-related pneumonia-related paper in the New England Journal of Medicine by the China Center for Disease Control and Prevention and other organizations, the journal responded to the news on the timing of the paper’s review. Jennifer Zeis, director of communications and media relations at the New England Journal of Medicine, told reporters that the report on the outbreak took only 48 hours from submission to publication.

Why the Chinese disease control paper is published so fast: New crown related papers published only 48 hours

Typically, top academic journals have a long review process that can range from weeks to months, but there is a precedent for a rapid review process in the event of a major public health event or major scientific breakthrough. The speed of publication of the paper is directly related to the importance of the paper. Jennifer Zeis says the New England Journal of Medicine has adopted similar rapid review slots in previous outbreaks, such as SARS and Ebola.

On January 29, 2020, local time, Feng Zijian, Deputy Director of the China Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Liang Zhuowei, Dean of the Faculty of Medicine of the University of Hong Kong, Gao Benn, Professor of the School of Public Health of the University of Hong Kong, and Yang Bo, Director of the Center for Disease Control and Prevention of Hubei Province, published a newsletter entitled “New England Journal of Medicine” A retrospective paper in the Journal of The Early Spreading Dynamics of Pneumonia of the New Coronary Virus infection in Wuhan, China, shows that human-to-human transmission occurred in December 2019 among close contacts.

In this regard, some netizens questioned that the author of the article failed to inform the public of this important information in time, and expressed the hope to know the author of this information at a specific time.

In a response statement, the CDC said the paper was based on a retrospective analysis of 425 confirmed cases reported as of January 23, 2020, including 15 medical personnel, and that all cases had been released to the public prior to the paper’s writing. Feng Zijian, deputy director of the China Center for Disease Control and Prevention, also told Caixin, “The CDC … Papers submitted from 25th to 26th. “

According to this statement, from the submission of the paper to publish about 4 days apart, and some netizens questioned: “Why can the paper be published so quickly in authoritative journals?” Is 4 days sufficient to complete the review process required for authoritative journals? Is this the exact publishing process?

In response to such questions, on January 31st, News corpus contacted the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM). Jennifer Zeis, director of communications and media relations at the New England Journal of Medicine, responded to the news that it was not possible to provide a date for the submission of specific papers, but that for the outbreak, “the time from submission to publication was as short as 48 hours.” “

Jennifer Zeis says details of the process are confidential for any particular paper. But she outlined to reporters the New England Journal of Medicine’s publication of papers related to the new coronavirus, “all of which are sent to experts for peer review and carefully edited by editors.” For this outbreak, the process has been greatly accelerated, from submission to publication time of 48 hours. In particular, she stressed that, despite the reduced time, the journal supped all review steps to ensure the rigour of the report.

The New England Journal of Medicine is a weekly magazine that also publishes papers online, usually every Thursday. In response to the outbreak, the journal set up a dedicated web page to summarize relevant papers (ORIGINAL ARTICLE) and views (PERSPECTIVE), etc., and published at a time not subject to the time limit for Thursday’s publication, the journalist found. Papers related to the new coronavirus have been published on Friday, January 24, January 29 (Wednesday), and January 31 (Friday), for example, the latest paper on the treatment of the first confirmed case in the United States and clinical performance, First Case of 2019 Coronavirus in The State Of it is published on Friday, January 31.

News learned from the official website of the New England Journal of Medicine that the journal is developing a set of operating specifications for contributions related to the new coronavirus (2019-nCoV). “We will quickly evaluate submissions and, if planned, speed up all editorial steps so that they can be published as soon as possible,” it said in an editorial published on January 27. “